Since the announcement of FXCM Canada that it was pulling out of the BC market in August, I have been absolutely bombarded with questions from BC residents – especially those FXCM Canada clients of what to do.
The option of transferring ones account to MF Global Canada (MF Global FX) – judging by the feedback I am receiving – doesn’t seem to satisfy traders. Indeed, when traders who are used to the margin levels they have been trading at, look at the margins offered by MF Global FX (which I personally don’t think are unreasonable at all – the whole purpose is to protect traders) they start looking elsewhere.
So what is elsewhere? If you’re a BC resident what do you do? Who do you open an account with? The global nature of the Forex market has reputable forex dealers doing business around the world. We only have to look south of the border to see some of the largest dealers not doing business in BC for one reason or another – only the BCSC truly knows.
As someone mentioned to me the other day, “The BCSC must be looking at things and think, if we can get all the Forex dealers to LEAVE BC, then the problem of people losing money in Forex goes away.”
In the past few years we’ve seen a number of dealers TRY to get into BC – FX Solutions and Forex.com being two – and both ended up white labeling their offerings through Questrade – which is a dubious dealer, devoid of any type of helpful customer service. I can only imagine that both of those big dealers are disappointed with the arrangement they have with Questrade.
So enough of the riff-raff, who are the ones who are registered with the BCSC you ask? Well, not only is the BCSC registration important here, but IIROC registration is a necessity. In December I posted Part I of Opening a Forex Account in BC, and this is the revision to that.
Registered with IIROC and BCSC:
- Interactive Brokers
- MF Global Canada
- Trade Freedom
- Questrade
All have its pros and cons. Some offer higher margins than others, they have differing minimum account openings (Interactive Brokers is $10,000 USD), and most have negligible customer service – as has been reported to me.
The significance of a dealer being registered with IIROC is that gets them automatic membership with the CIPF which insures trader accounts to upwards of $1 million, for a variety of causes. Registration with the BCSC just allows those dealers to solicit and accept accounts from BC residents.
Nothing the BCSC does restricts a BC resident from opening a dealer account with anyone in the world. If you open an account with a dealer that will take you as a BC resident then it’s your risk, and you have to be aware of what those risks are.
What is most important is for a trader to know his/her trading profile. What tools does a trader need? What functionality in their trading does a trader need? Once a trader understands what their needs are, they will be in a better position to determine what dealer they open an account with.
Add your comments, I’d love to hear them. I’m always learning more about the needs of traders and the original post in December had 37 comments. I’ll revise this post and add additional thoughts as time goes on, but the dialogue with traders is most important.